The theology of Christianity is a little confusing. On the one hand, it is forbidden and considered heresy for a Christian to claim that he is one with God, yet on the other hand, the Holy Spirit is supposed to come over him and guide him. And all three – God the Father, Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit – are seen as the one God.
Nowadays, many Christians in the West no longer follow the dogmas of the Church, but take the sayings of Jesus and Bhakti as guideline. Therefore, many even claim that God is within, as Jesus himself said “the Kingdom of heaven is within you”.
Hindus can point out to Christians those aspects, where Jesus, in contrast to the Church, is in line with the Indian Rishis.
For example, Jesus made the Upanishadic statement, “I and my Father are one” (Aham Brahmasmi). Unfortunately, and shrewdly, the Church declared that this claim is valid only for Jesus. This of course doesn’t make sense.
Another point:
When once asked what is the most important commandment to follow if one wants to reach heaven, Jesus said, “the greatest commandment is to love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, and mind, followed closely by loving your neighbor as yourself.”
This teaching is recorded in the Gospels of Matthew 22:36–40 and Mark 12:28–31.
It means, Jesus was foremost advocating Love for God or Bhakti, which is a most important path also for Hindus, and for anyone who wants to realise the Truth.
Yet the Church ignored what Jesus had advocated and declared as its first commandment: ‘you shall not have other gods before me’, which is also the first commandment in Judaism. In Islam, too, shirk (Idol-worship) is considered as the greatest sin.
It is surely strange, that the Church ignored what Jesus said about “the greatest commandment” and does not mention the Bhakti aspect in its Ten Commandments.
Christians may counter, “What the Church meant by its first commandment, is that, first we need to make sure that we worship the true God, and only we, the Christians, have the true God and you, Hindus, have false Gods.”
Now, it needs to be understood – first by Hindus themselves, because many don’t know it any longer – and then it needs also be conveyed to Indian Christians:
It needs to be understood that Vedic wisdom claims that there is absolute, eternal Truth, and relative, temporary truth.
Absolute truth is That which is really true. It means it must be always and must be self-evident.
It can be logically concluded and experienced that only eternal, unchanging Consciousness (Brahman, in English called God or Godhead) is really true. All else is Maya, it is a temporary appearance on this truth. This wisdom is universally valid and independent by what name one calls that one Truth, whether Brahman, God, Yahwe, Allah, Pure Mind…
An analogy makes it clear:
in a movie hall, the ever-changing pictures of the movie cover the movie screen. Yet the invisible, white (pure) screen is the only real thing in the movie, all else, including the people, houses, etc. are temporary appearances whose substance is the one screen. The happenings in the movie are more like virtual reality. This should make sense nowadays. Elon Musk, too, said that this apparent reality is not the real thing.
It follows naturally, that discovering the ‘real thing’ (Brahman) is the goal of life.
The Abrahamic religions do not have this absolute Truth level. Their great (good) God and its opposite, the (evil) Satan, are within Maya, more in tune with the Devas and Asuras/Rakshasas of Hinduism. Their God ‘speaks’ to certain people, has likes and dislikes and even has feelings of revenge.
Judaism was the first Abrahamic religion that claimed that the one great God, Yahweh, has chosen the Israelites as his special people. It is said that Yahweh first made this promise through a covenant with Abraham and later reaffirmed it to Isaac (Abraham’s son) and to Jacob, called Israel (Isaac’s son).
God here favoured basically a tribe, and not a belief system.
Moses, who received and passed on the ten commandments for the Jews, lived several centuries later. (It’s not clear, since when the decedents of Jacob were called Jews.)
When Jesus showed up in Palestine at age 30 after a long hiatus of 18 years, he criticized the leaders of the Jews very strongly. He called them even children of the devil (John 8.44), as, according to him, they didn’t follow Moses’ instructions any longer. Not long after, at the age of 33, Jesus was crucified.
The Christian Church basically opened up the narrow circle of God’s chosen people from a tribe to all mankind, however under one condition: they need to be members of the Church and accept Jesus Christi as their saviour.
Now the one true God is favouring no longer only a tribe, but all Christians.
A few centuries later, Islam was founded. It is close to Judaism in many aspects, but the great God is no longer called Yahwe but Allah. Islam declared Mohammed the last prophet, who received the final instructions from Allah.
Now, the one true God, called Allah, favoured only Muslims.
The question may be asked: whom does the true God favour? Or is he free from favouritism?
If there were an open, genuine dialogue, Hindus can surely make a convincing case for the insights of their Rishis being closer to Truth. The Cause of the Universe is not favouring a special group, depending on their DNA or belief. Truth is the one Essence in all. It cannot be put in words or thoughts. Words can only point to the truth inside and help realising it.
To improve relations with Christians, Hindus can try to make Indian Christians reflect if the dogmas of the Church look true or if they are rather ‘unbelievable’.
Hindus also need to point out that the accusation that Hindus worship false Gods does not apply, simply, because only one ‘thing’ (not a thing of course) is true and everything is contained in that. All the apparently different Devas or Gods are different aspects of the one Brahman.
Another point: I know from Germany, that Christians are often critical of their priests and bishops. It may be the case also in India. Especially the higher clergy may be corrupt – morally and financially. If caught, such news should reach the Christian community. It helps to loosen the bond with the Church dogmas.
For Christians to have bhakti for Jesus is helpful and in tune with Hindu Dharma. But the claim that ALL must accept Jesus as their saviour is the obstacle for good relations between Hindus and Christians.
Most lay Christians in Europe no longer subscribe to that unreasonable exclusivity claim that only Christians can be saved. Indian Christians are usually stronger indoctrinated than western Christians. I have seen this in a Christian ashram in Tamil Nadu:
The head of the ashram (Bede Griffith who has passed away in the 1990s. He is on the picture), was teaching a group of Indian nun novices. I stayed on for his talk and was shocked, how strongly Father Bede claimed that only the Church is right. He had never talked like this to us foreigners. I went straight to him afterwards, and burst out, “Father Bede how could you say this?” (I don’t remember exactly what). His reply: “I have to strengthen their faith, so that they know where the boundary to Hinduism is…”
It was disappointing. While he talked to us foreigners about Vedanta, he wanted to make sure that Indian Christians are not tempted to fall back into the faith of their ancestors.
So yes, Indian Christians are stronger indoctrinated. But if they genuinely reflect, they may come to the conclusion that – maybe – it’s not true that only Christians go to heaven…
Hindus should support them in reflecting on the truth. To call them rice-bags, as some Hindus do, is not quite fair and also not advisable. It would only antagonise them and make them more closed-minded.
After all, the goal is to live in harmony and mutual kindness together.
By Maria Wirth
link to all my books
https://www.amazon.in/s?k=maria+wirth
My latest book “Why Hindu Dharma is under attack by Muslims, Christians and the Left” is available on Amazon both in English and Hindi.
My earlier book is only in English “Thank you India – a German woman’s journey to the wisdom of Yoga”
